“We want to give borrowers more control.” These words from Mark Martella, Lending Manager at Sacramento Credit Union, reflect his commitment to helping credit union members save money on mortgage insurance (MI). Mark is focusing on California homeowners facing high mortgage insurance costs, which range from 0.46% to 1.50% of the loan amount annually*. For a $300,000 mortgage, this equates to $1,380 to $4,500 per year—or $115 to $375 per month—adding significant strain to monthly budgets already stretched by mortgage payments, property taxes, and other obligations.
Mortgage insurance has long been a challenge for homeowners. Required for buyers with less than a 20% down payment, its cost is determined by factors such as credit score, loan amount, property type, and debt-to-income ratio. Borrowers with credit scores below 740 or high debt-to-income ratios face even higher costs. Yet, the current system offers little flexibility to reduce premiums, even when borrowers improve their financial standing.
Through Mark efforts, Sacramento Credit Union is exploring a groundbreaking idea: allowing borrowers to modify or rewrite their mortgage insurance policies when their credit improves or their financial risk decreases. This initiative seeks to give homeowners greater control over their finances while aligning with the credit union’s philosophy of prioritizing member well-being.
The problem with mortgage insurance
Many homeowners share a common frustration: improving their credit scores or reducing their debt-to-income ratios does not result in lower mortgage insurance premiums. Unlike homeowner’s insurance, which can be adjusted at any time, mortgage insurance remains tied to the original terms of the loan. The only option for borrowers to reduce these costs is through a full loan refinance—a process that can cost thousands of dollars in fees and may lead to higher interest rates.
A bold solution
Mark’s proposal first gained attention at the california and nevada credit union leagues’ reach conference, where he suggested enabling borrowers to “refinance” or rewrite their mortgage insurance policies. The concept resonated with credit union peers and industry professionals, garnering interest from several large credit unions, including some with multi-billion-dollar portfolios.
Now, a growing coalition of credit unions is exploring a pilot program to bring this vision to life. The program focuses on portfolio loans, avoiding the complexities of involving major investors like fannie mae. starting with 25 credit unions across california and nevada, the initiative would allow borrowers to adjust their mortgage insurance policies based on improved financial circumstances, providing much-needed flexibility and savings.
A grassroots movement for change
This initiative exemplifies the grassroots spirit of credit unions. “what is more credit union than this?” mark asks. “this type of effort to help our members is exactly why we’re in business.” by advocating for financial fairness and prioritizing member needs, the program aligns with the core mission of credit unions.
To succeed, partnerships with mortgage insurance companies will be essential. Sacramento credit union plans to work with mi providers to highlight the mutual benefits of empowering homeowners, ultimately reshaping the financial landscape for millions of families. This collaboration could also positively impact both the credit union and mortgage insurance industries, demonstrating the power of shared goals.
What could be more credit union than that?